Neurologic benefit of Lyme therapy short-lived
Tuesday, March 25th, 2008Lyme encephalopathy, infection of the membrane lining the brain, is usually mild to moderate in severity, but it can affect a number of cognitive functions, including memory, verbal fluency and psychomotor performance, Dr. B. A. Fallon and associates note in the medical journal Neurology.
Most patients show marked improvements in cognitive function following a 4-week course of intravenous antibiotic treatment with ceftriaxone, but some patients experience little or no improvements.
The best therapy for these patients is unclear, in large part because the underlying cause is unclear, the report indicates. The persistent cognitive deficits could be related to the effects of a past infection; Borrelia burgdorferi, another tick-borne infection; an unrecognized coinfection; or an incorrect diagnosis.
Treatment approaches to patients with this complication have ranged from observation only, to the treatment of symptoms only, to extended courses of antibiotics.
Fallon, from Columbia University in New York, and colleagues investigated the benefits of 10 weeks of intravenous ceftriaxone (trade name Rocephin) in patients with previously treated Lyme disease who continued to show memory impairments and tested positive for Lyme disease using a Western blot.
A total of 37 patients were randomly assigned to receive intravenous ceftriaxone or placebo (saline solution) for 10 weeks. The study also included 20 healthy individuals to serve as a comparison group.
In addition to having mild-to-moderate cognitive impairment, the patients suffered from fatigue, pain and impaired physical functioning, the report shows.
By week 12, numerous areas in cognitive function improved with antibiotic therapy compared with placebo. However, by evaluation at week 24, the improvements had largely disappeared.
Patients with more severe pain, fatigue, and impaired physical functioning who were treated with the antibiotic showed improvement at 12 weeks - and improvements in pain and physical functioning were still apparent after 24 weeks.
Mild, transient adverse events were noted in 6 of 23 patients (26.1 percent) given antibiotic therapy and in 1 of 14 (7.1 percent) who received placebo.
In agreement with data from three previous randomized studies, these findings clearly show "the absence of any lasting improvement in cognitive function" with prolonged antibiotic therapy, Dr. John J. Halperin, from the Atlantic Neuroscience Institute in Summit, New Jersey, writes in a related editorial.
"Given the considerable risk of serious adverse events from prolonged antibiotic treatment, it is time to look elsewhere for an effective management strategy to help patients with persistent cognitive symptoms after treatment for Lyme disease. Clearly, enough is enough."
SOURCE: Neurology, March 25, 2008.
Copyright © 2008 Reuters Limited.